evil
aka Evil
Jay Dyer treats evil as a privation, lacking substantive existence and understood as a movement away from goodness, contrasting this with Enlightenment views that attribute moral failures to ignorance and critiquing interpretations that grant ontological status to evil. He emphasizes that evil arises from the misuse of free will and is not created by God, presenting a nuanced understanding that differentiates between moral transgression and other interpretations of evil as deprivation or calamity.
Chain 6 of 22 pieces
Jay Dyer argues that evil has no being or metaphysical status and is understood as a privation or movement away from the good, rather than a substantive existence.
Jay argues that the concept of evil in scripture is often misunderstood, suggesting it denotes a lack of good or refers to calamity rather than an independent ontological existence.
- 2023-08-19Open Forum Debate: Islam, Trinity, Hypostatic Union, Filioque, Energies - Jay Dyer1:57:391:58:15
Jay states that there are different senses in which the word 'evil' is used, including deprivation and moral transgression, and that misunderstandings arise when one believes 'evil' has a single meaning.
Led intohypostasis - 2025-08-15Tucker, Candace, Jones, Gossip & Virtues, Cults, Espionage & Charismatics: Jay Dyer Show3:47:103:47:213:47:44
Jay asserts that evil has no ontological basis or substance, referencing discussions from church fathers such as Athanasius and Augustine.
- 2026-05-16HEATED DEBATES! CRASHOUT CONTINUES! DAILY WIRE, CHOLO CHURCH, JAY ON PIERS MORGAN!1:09:051:10:17
Jay claims that evil is the misuse of good or good things, stating that it does not have ontological status but exists through actions against the moral law.
Led intoMarxism - 2026-06-29Skeptic DEBATE! Scripture / Tradition? Resource Control, Byzantium & History, Generational Legacy49:5450:2252:01
Jay Dyer argues that intelligence can exist alongside extreme wickedness, suggesting that vice can cloud judgment and lead to self-destructive behavior.
Discussed in
- videoPAGANISM & Debating Atheism, Free Will & Modalism! - Jay Dyer
- videoSkeptic DEBATE! Scripture / Tradition? Resource Control, Byzantium & History, Generational Legacy
- videoVoodoo Hollywood w/Jamie Hanshaw: Q n A and Hollywood Hoodoo (half)
- videoTucker, Candace, Jones, Gossip & Virtues, Cults, Espionage & Charismatics: Jay Dyer Show
- videoOPEN DEBATE! Heretic Pope? Islam, Protestantism, Gnosticism, Hebrew Roots, Mormon, Etc vs Jay Dyer
- videoHEATED DEBATES! CRASHOUT CONTINUES! DAILY WIRE, CHOLO CHURCH, JAY ON PIERS MORGAN!
- videoThe Psychology of the Left: History & Analysis -Jay Dyer
- videoOPEN DEBATE: Roman Catholic MELTDOWNS, Islamic Debates, Atheism, Protestantism vs Jay Dyer
- videoOPEN DEBATE! Libertarianism & Theism - Vs Jay Dyer
- videoSHAMANISM??? Jordan Peterson & John Vervaeke's Meaning Crisis @ChurchoftheEternalLogos & Jay Dyer
- videoAliens, Demons & God: Rocker DOROTHY Joins Me to Discuss!
- videoOpen Forum Debate: Islam, Trinity, Hypostatic Union, Filioque, Energies - Jay Dyer
- videoTop 10 Errors Everyone Makes! FUNKOPOCALYPSE METAPHYSICS! - Jay Dyer
- videoPagan Philosophy, Pagan Literature & Virtue, Epistemology & Natural Law - Jay Dyer / Fr Dcn Ananias
- videoBitcoin, The Divine Mind, The Bible & Economics, TAG - Open Forum Q n A & Debate - Jay Dyer
- videoDEBATE REACTION: God's Existence - Trent Horn Vs. CosmicSkeptic - Jay Dyer
- videoJay Dyer Vs Rome, Protestants, Islam and More! - Jay Dyer
- videoEveryone's Going NUTS: Atheism, God & State - Jay Dyer + JimBob
- videoLost Wisdom, Lost Biblical Books! Pt 2 - Jay Dyer (Half)
- videoJesus' Atonement? Christology, Essence - Energy BK III - Ep 9 - Jay Dyer (Half)
- videoNatural Law and Natural Theology Don't Exist - Traditional Philosophy Ep 7 - Jay Dyer
- videoJordan Peterson Vs Sam Harris Part 1 - Jay Dyer's Debate Review