Content

Enneads of Plotinus Deconstructed (Half) – Jay Dyer

videoJay Dyer2017-05-31watch ↗

In his piece, Jay Dyer examines the interplay between Neoplatonism and Christianity, drawing on Michael Hoffman's book 'The Occult Renaissance Church of Rome' to critique elements of Augustine's theology, particularly the Filioque, which Dyer believes inadvertently resonates with Arianism. He delves into the influence of Plotinus and the foundations of Western philosophy, arguing that many contemporary philosophical ideas are rooted in earlier heresies that contradict Orthodox Christian beliefs. Dyer presents Plotinian philosophy as a potential corruption of Christian thought and highlights key distinctions in concepts such as resurrection and the nature of God, asserting that they misunderstand Orthodox theological principles. He critiques the Neoplatonic emanation process and its hierarchical implications, emphasizing its divergence from the true understanding of the Holy Trinity in Orthodox theology.

Chain 6 steps

    • Jay Dyer: Hoffman's critique of Roman Catholicism is credible and aligns with historical critiques.“everything I've seen so far is pretty solid.”
    via Augustine of Hippo
    • Jay Dyer: Augustine critiques the pagan world and presents an orthodox perspective in 'City of God'.“Augustine's critique of the pagan world, the City of Man, as he calls it...”
    • Jay Dyer: Plotinus' metaphysics suggests a journey of the soul to its divine origin, contrasting with Christianity.“the object of life is to understand how we might restore that soul to its original sort of proper place.”
    • Jay Dyer: Plotinus's philosophy excludes special revelation and relies on philosophy for knowledge.“there's no access to the to the divine through any kind of special revelation”
    • Other speaker: The concept of the one in Plotinus is ineffable and non-personal.“the one is said to overflow in this way as a kind of emanation”
    • Other speaker: Relates the emanation theory to the notion of unity in God.“the father we we believe is the rk or or prime principle of the trinity”

Subjects

7
  • Jay critiques Plotinus's philosophy, suggesting it lacks access to the divine through special revelation and presents an ineffable concept of the one.

  • Jay critiques Augustine's influence on Christian doctrine, particularly regarding the Filioque, arguing his views lead to Arianism.

  • Jay describes the one as an ineffable principle which is beyond being and is fundamentally non-personal and apophatic.

  • Jay critiques the use of Neoplatonic thought in understanding God, emphasizing that Christian theology should be grounded in Scripture.

  • Jay argues that the Filioque contradicts Orthodox teachings and is not biblically based, framing it as an Arian argument.

  • Jay considers the influence of Egyptian theology on monotheism and contrasts it with the views of Plotinus, particularly concerning the idea of bodily resurrection.

  • Jay Dyer notes that Celsus, a Neoplatonist, presents arguments portraying Christianity as foolish.