Content

Filioque? History of a Doctrinal Controversy - Fr Dcn Dr Ananias / Dyer / Lewis

In his examination of the Filioque controversy, Jay Dyer engages with various perspectives on this theological debate between Eastern Orthodoxy and Western Christianity, focusing on its historical complexities and nuances. He critiques significant figures from the Latin tradition, such as Augustine and Thomas Aquinas, while emphasizing the Orthodox view that acknowledges the Holy Spirit's unique procession from the Father. Dyer highlights the impact of mistranslation and misunderstanding throughout ecclesiastical history and discusses the implications of the debate for contemporary ecumenism and Church unity. Through scholarly analysis and dialogue, he advocates for a deeper understanding of the theological positions involved, reflecting on the importance of maintaining good relationships despite doctrinal disagreements.

Chain 6 steps

    • Fr Dcn Dr Ananias: Basil and Gregory emphasize that we cannot equate epistemic order with ontological order in understanding the Trinity.β€œWe Should Note Too That This Is Another Issue That I Noticed Is Popping Up In A Lot Of Debates”
    via St. Basil the Great
    • Jay Dyer: Augustine's shift in Trinitarian concepts led to confusion.β€œSo Then We Get To The Section Of Augustine”
    • Jay Dyer: The theological debate around the Filioque has persisted through centuries.β€œThese debates take many centuries... You can't just look at the letter to Marinus...”
    • Jay Dyer: The rejection of the Seventh Ecumenical Council by Charlemagne and Frankish theologians signifies a rupture with Byzantium.β€œIt's a political thing that results in the rejection of the Seventh Ecumenical Council.”
    • Fr Dcn Dr Ananias: Anselm introduces essentialist tendencies that lead to confusion in Trinitarian theology.β€œwith Anselm we have the beginning of the primacy of essentialism”
    • Other speaker: Pope Eugene IV had genuine intentions for Church unity.β€œPope Eugene The Fourth Genuinely Wanted A Reunion”

Subjects

20
  • Jay Dyer critiques the confusion between the Holy Spirit and the bond of love concerning the Filioque controversy.

  • Jay Dyer notes that Basil defended the full deity of the Holy Spirit against heretical views and emphasized the Spirit's equality within the Trinity.

  • Jay Dyer critiques Augustine's role in the theological shift regarding the procession of the Holy Spirit, acknowledging a significant change in his thought over time.

  • Jay presents the Council of Florence as a historical moment that illustrates the theological tensions and geopolitical pressures surrounding the Filioque debate.

  • Jay Dyer highlights that Maximus is clear about the energetic procession through the Son and emphasizes that Maximus would not have accepted the Florentine Filioque formulation.

  • Jay Dyer highlights the significance of Shashansky's work in providing a thorough and non-polemical survey of the Filioque controversy.

  • Jay discusses Gregory II of Cyprus's positions, highlighting the importance of his views in the context of the Filioque controversy and asserts the need to adhere to his teachings against the Latin doctrine.

  • Jay refers to St. Mark of Ephesus as someone who resisted the compromises proposed at the Council of Florence and maintained the Orthodox stance on the Filioque.

  • Jay Dyer critiques Anselm for promoting essentialist views that lead to confusion regarding the nature of the Trinity.

  • Jay Dyer mentions Bonaventure as a key figure who contributed to the theological issues surrounding the Filioque, following Anselm's essentialism.

  • Jay Dyer notes that the election of Charlemagne created geopolitical problems and signified a declaration of independence from Byzantium.

  • Jay Dyer recommends Papadakis' 'Crisis in Byzantium' as a valuable addition to understanding the Orthodox perspective on the Filioque issue.