Debating Roman Catholic Absolute Simplicity & Aquinas: Jay Dyer Vs. Dr. Francis Feingold
In his debates, Jay Dyer engages with Dr. Francis Feingold on the topic of divine simplicity, particularly as presented by Thomas Aquinas, and its implications for understanding Godβs nature, the Trinity, and salvation. Dyer critiques Aquinas' notion of absolute simplicity, arguing that it obscures the distinction between God's essence and energies, while also raising concerns about its compatibility with the relationships within the Trinity. Feingold defends Aquinas by emphasizing the coherence of divine simplicity with classical philosophical principles and its potential to explain divine attributes. Throughout their discussions, they explore complex theological concepts, including the hypostatic origins of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, as well as the broader implications for grace and revelation in Eastern Orthodox and Roman Catholic traditions. The dialogue reveals significant theological differences, particularly regarding the nature of divine love and the limitations of human understanding in relation to divine qualities.
Chain 6 steps
- Dr. Francis Feingold: Aquinas' doctrine of divine simplicity is rooted in the necessity of a first cause.βthe basic reason for affirming divine simplicity comes from affirming... the first causeβ
via divine simplicity- Dr. Francis Feingold: Divine simplicity is rooted in Aristotelian reasoning about God's nature as first cause.βThat's an Aristotelian doctrine.β
via Ben Shapiro- Dr. Francis Feingold: Aquinas's doctrine of absolute simplicity does not work.βthat it doesn't workβ
via John Wesley- Dr. Francis Feingold: Roman Catholic theology accepts a form of divine simplicity that is compatible with the Trinity based on Aquinas' view.βthat's impossible because number one the son can't participate in the father's hypostasisβ
- Dr. Francis Feingold: Roman Catholic doctrine does not properly recognize the distinction between God's essence and His energies.βyou don't believe that god's goodness was manifest distinct from the essence of godβ
- Dr. Francis Feingold: One can infer divine qualities from the observed actions of love in the world.βif you see the operation right so i don't have any direct access to your love and i never will all that I have access to is your operations of loveβ
Subjects
20Jay Dyer critiques the application of Aquinas's notion of absolute divine simplicity, arguing that this view complicates the understanding of God's love in relation to human experience.
Jay argues that the doctrine of divine simplicity as articulated by Aquinas is problematic and stems from Greek philosophical origins.
Jay refers to Gregory of Nyssa's writings as a counter-argument against Eunomius's view on divine simplicity.
Jay Dyer upholds classic Orthodox Trinitarianism, emphasizing the unique relationships of hypostasis among Father, Son, and Holy Spirit.
Jay references John of Damascus as making a distinction between eternal manifestation and hypostatic origin, particularly in the context of the filioque issue.
Jay argues that the filioque doctrine introduces problems related to the subordination of the Holy Spirit when understood alongside Aquinas's absolute simplicity.
Jay presents the Orthodox view that the Father is the only source of the Holy Spirit, emphasizing a distinction between the mission of the Spirit and its eternal manifestation.
Jay cites Saint Maximus Confessor as part of the Eastern Orthodox tradition that offers a better understanding of divine relationships.
Jay mentions Eunomius as a point of comparison to Aquinas, particularly in their shared claims regarding divine simplicity.
Jay argues that the Father is the sole source of the Spirit, which corresponds to the Orthodox understanding of hypostatic origin.
Jay discusses Dionysius the Areopagite's distinction between essence and energy, emphasizing that one cannot reach God's essence through reasoning.
Jay Dyer mentions the Athanasian Creed's status and clarifies that Orthodoxy does not accept it as authored by Athanasius, but agrees with its assertion that all three persons of the Trinity are uncreated.