Content

Thread: Popular IG’er “Jesusandwhatnot” allegedly called in and tried the typical Thomist tactic…

threadJay Dyer2026-08-07watch ↗

Popular IG’er “Jesusandwhatnot” allegedly called in and tried the typical Thomist tactic of “just grant me neutrality and self-evidence!” When he saw that didn’t work, he conceded he couldn’t defend Thomism’s first principles but still wanted me to argue as if we have the same first principles and paradigm. It was the exact mirror of every atheist evidentialist argumentation. Thomism is only as good as the foundationalism it’s built on and if that fails, the whole edifice falls, just like atheism, Islam and Rome - all of which share the same faulty starting points of empirical sense data. LOL…

Chain 2 of 2 · 1 replies

  1. Jay Dyer

    JesusandWhatnot can't defend Thomism

    “concede he couldn’t defend Thomism’s first principles”

Subjects

2
  • Jay describes 'JesusandWhatnot' as cowardly for not using his public account to debate and failing to defend Thomism.

  • Jay critiques Thomism for its reliance on flawed foundationalism, claiming that if its first principles fail, the whole structure collapses.