Content

Roots / Voice of Reason misquoted their papal quote-mine, showing they didn’t actually re…

threadJay Dyer2026-07-04watch ↗

Roots / Voice of Reason misquoted their papal quote-mine, showing they didn’t actually read the homily. They cite the Schaff set sermon “4,” but it’s sermon 3. This means they lazily quote-mined a brief homily that is largely about the merits of St Peter himself. There is no sermon 4 in the schaff set (it goes from 3 to 9). This is also absurd reasoning since there are 3 Petrine sees, up to even Gregory the Great so this line of reasoning would mean Rome, Antioch and Alexandria are all infallible popes, since “Peters merits live on in his successors” lol. Below is the actual homily which does…

Chain 1 of 1

  1. Jay Dyer

    Critiques a misquote of a papal homily by Roots / Voice of Reason.

    “Roots / Voice of Reason misquoted their papal quote-mine”