Thread: According to Vatican 1, Rome is the final arbiter of what the authentic tradition is, not…
According to Vatican 1, Rome is the final arbiter of what the authentic tradition is, not French bishops. Since the second millennium the pope literally confirms all bishops in the world. There are 4 separate statements in Denzinger that ordinary magisterium & papal excommunications are absolutely binding. The exact same principles behind why Old Catholics are schismatics (in papism) are the principles why SSPX are textbook schismatics. In reality of this is a false dialectic between two rival schisms which are far removed from the first millennium of obvious conciliarism and synodality. / fo…
Chain 3 of 3 · 2 replies
- Jay Dyer
Critique of Vatican I and the authority of Pope and Bishops.
“According to Vatican 1, Rome is the final arbiter of what the authentic tradition is...”
Subjects
3Jay references Denzinger to support his argument about the authority of the pope and the binding nature of papal excommunications.
Jay critiques papism as a false dialectic between two schisms, stating it is far removed from traditional conciliarism and synodality.
Jay characterizes SSPX as schismatic in relation to Catholic orthodoxy.