Content

To @timotheeology: Your papacy is Talmudic

threadJay Dyer2026-02-27watch ↗

Your papacy is Talmudic / / / amazing that after years of debates and explaining the em different systems you can’t grasp a system level difference: patriarchs arent indefectible. your papacy supposedly is and this is being a promoter of absolute heresy. / Tim - I said indefectibility - which you just ignored and obfuscated with infallibility. / when he promoted the Talmud he defected. papacy ended / it means he cannot become a public heretic and defect. There is nothing in being a heretic which requires it be binding - this is what you all make up to move the goalposts. martin luther was a…

Chain 2 of 2 · 1 replies

  1. Jay Dyer

    Critiques the papacy's claims of indefectibility

    “your papacy supposedly is and this is being a promoter of absolute heresy.”

Subjects

2
  • Jay Dyer argues against the concept of papal indefectibility, claiming that the papacy can become a promoter of heresy.

  • Jay Dyer argues that the promotion of the Talmud by a pope signifies a defect in the papacy itself.