Content

Orthodoxy, Catholicism, Thomism & Palamas - Jay Dyer & Fr Moody (Half)

videoJay DyerFr Moody2016-02-23watch β†—

In a comprehensive discussion, Jay Dyer and Father Chris Moody examine the significant theological differences between Eastern Orthodox and Roman Catholic beliefs, particularly focusing on the implications of their respective epistemologies. They critique Thomism's reliance on Aristotelian philosophy, arguing that it distorts the understanding of God's nature and the relationship between divine essence and human knowledge. The conversation delves into how these theological distinctions influence contemporary issues like atheism and the occult, the concept of theosis, and the experience of divine grace. They also highlight concerns about the desacralization of nature in Catholic and Protestant traditions, ultimately suggesting a more direct communion with God found within Orthodox practice.

Chain 6 steps

    • Fr Moody: The differences in theology between Eastern Orthodoxy and Roman Catholicism extend beyond the papacy and involve deeper theological concepts.β€œthere are primary differences between...Roman Catholic theology and their views of God...as opposed to Eastern Orthodox theology?”
    via St. Gregory Renounce the Andrews
    • Fr Moody: There are limited views on theism, leading to pantheism or absolute simplicity.β€œyou can either have a kind of pagan version of polytheism or henotheism... or you can have a kind of, you know, deistic or Islamic or whatever notion of absolute simplicity.”
    via Augustine of Hippo
    • Jay Dyer: Thomism's understanding of knowledge is insufficient.β€œthe way that we have supernatural knowledge is the exact same.”
    via Thomism
    • Fr Moody: Issue of theosis in Catholicism and Protestantismβ€œ...even the indwelling of the Holy Spirit in either of these categories is never a real theosis...”
    • Fr Moody: Crisis in the Catholic Churchβ€œ...the Church was, of course, in crisis prior to that.”
    • Fr Moody: Papal infallibility has evolved over time, as acknowledged by Pope Benedict XVI.β€œthe first thousand years of the papacy was not grounded in the notion of infallibility.”

Subjects

15
  • Jay Dyer emphasizes the significance of St. Gregory Palamas in discussing the distinction between divine essence and energies, highlighting his critique of Western epistemology.

  • Jay critiques Thomism, stating it ultimately desacralizes nature and leads to a flawed understanding of God.

  • Jay Dyer reflects on his past as a hardcore Augustinian and how Augustine's theology influenced his journey into Catholicism.

  • Jay Dyer critiques Aquinas' approach to divine simplicity and the idea of the divine essence as problematic within Thomism.

  • Jay Dyer engages with the works of Dionysius and discusses the complexities and potential non-orthodox elements in his writings.

  • Jay discusses theosis and how it is explicitly referenced in scripture, emphasizing that understanding spiritual truths goes beyond mere reasoning.

  • Aristotle's materialist perspective contrasts with Plato's idealism, leading to differing views on knowledge and epistemology.

  • Jay discusses how Thomism's view of divine essence leads to problematic conclusions about God's attributes.

  • Father Chris Moody, a Greek Orthodox priest, has provided insights into how Palamite theology has shaped his understanding of ecumenism and the decline of Western thought.

  • Jay mentions how hesychasm relates to the experience of God compared to Western theology.

  • Jay notes the Eastern teaching that the light seen at Mount Tabor is divinity, contrasting with Roman Catholic assertions of it being a created light.

  • Plato's philosophy, particularly regarding the world of forms and the union with these forms, is contrasted with Aristotle's empiricism in the discussion about knowledge.