Content

Eternal Logos, Apophaticism & Simplicity - Jay Dyer/Eternal Logos/Snek

videoJay DyerPatrick2020-02-04watch ↗

In this episode, Jay Dyer engages with guest Snek, who shares his journey from nihilism and atheism to Eastern Orthodoxy, highlighting the challenges of integrating Orthodox faith into contemporary life. The discussion includes deep explorations of Orthodox theological concepts such as apophaticism, the distinction between God's essence and energies, and critiques of Thomistic theology, emphasizing the personal nature of God and the importance of accurate theological definitions. Dyer also addresses the philosophical implications of divine nature, the limitations of atheistic worldviews, and the necessity of grounding apologetic arguments in Orthodox theology to better navigate complex existential questions. The dialogue examines early church teachings and the challenges posed by contemporary interpretations of Christology, ultimately advocating for a clear understanding of Orthodox beliefs while exploring their relevance within broader philosophical discussions.

Chain 6 steps

    • Patrick: He shares his background, including his studies in various philosophies and religions.“So it really started about my undergraduate. I was interested in East Asian traditions.”
    • Patrick: The book 'God, History, and Dialectics' is essential for understanding Orthodoxy.“this was probably out of all the things I read, the most essential and most important book”
    via divine simplicity
    • Jay Dyer: The filioque leads to the erosion of distinctions within the Trinity, which is a fundamental error.“You are destroying the Trinity with the filioque. Exactly. And you are destroying many attributes that are very important.”
    • Jay Dyer: Logos encompasses more than logic; it's the second person of the Godhead.“the logos is not just a, an idea of logic or order, but that you have to recognize that he's the second person of the Godhead.”
    • Jay Dyer: Classical foundationalism fails to provide a proper basis for knowledge and justified belief.“we can't be classical foundationalists...”
    via Maximus the Confessor
    • Patrick: The Jesus Sutras provide a historical blending of Christian doctrine with Eastern thought.“the book's really interesting because it talks about this history of Christianity, Oriental Christianity.”

Subjects

43
  • Jay Dyer critiques Thomas Aquinas for his abstract philosophical approach, arguing that it lacks a focus on the personhood of God and fails to reveal God's nature as understood in Orthodox theology.

  • Jay questions the understanding of the term 'logos,' contemplating its implications in various philosophical and theological contexts.

  • Jay Dyer references St. Maximus, who teaches that all names of God we use refer to divine energies and not to the essence itself, emphasizing the importance of distinguishing divine energies in Orthodox theology.

  • Jay Dyer argues against the concept of absolute divine simplicity, stating that it leads to a misunderstanding of God's nature and contradicts the idea of divine energies, which are essential for maintaining God's interaction with creation.

  • Jay Dyer references Gregory Palamas to emphasize the Orthodox understanding of God's existence, contrasting it with classical theist perspectives.

  • Jay mentions that books like the Jesus Sutras accurately do comparative religion.

  • Jay references St. Dionysius' work to illustrate how God reveals himself through rays and energies.

  • Jay Dyer critiques common apologetic methods for relying on weak arguments and emphasizes the importance of addressing presuppositions in dialogue.

  • Jay Dyer mentions the Synod of Black Renee as a confirmation of the Palamite teachings and as evidence against the Catholic understanding of the Trinity.

  • Jay explains that Orthodox Christianity sees man as having a body, soul, and an intellectual aspect which includes the noose, contrasting with Western dualism.

  • Jay discusses apophatic theology, emphasizing that it aligns with a transcendental argument approach in apologetics, which he finds the most consistent if one believes in it.

  • Jay Dyer claims that mankind's problem is fundamentally moral, not metaphysical, pointing to Adam's moral failure rather than a lack of being.