Trinity Doctrine, Catholicism Vs Orthodoxy & Palamas on Essence - Energy - Jay Dyer (Half)
In his examination of the Trinity doctrine, Jay Dyer contrasts Eastern Orthodoxy with Catholicism, particularly through the teachings of St. Gregory Palamas on the essence and energies of God. He critiques Thomism for conflating God's essence with His actions, which he argues results in problematic theological conclusions, including the potential heresy of equating the Father with Christ's crucifixion. Dyer highlights the significance of apophatic theology in comprehending God's unknowable nature, asserting that true understanding comes through revelation rather than philosophical speculation. He also emphasizes the transformative nature of participating in God's grace and the importance of inner prayer and experiential knowledge in approaching the divine.
Chain 6 steps
- Jay Dyer: Eastern Orthodox theology maintains that there is a distinction between God's eternal actions and His actions related to creation.“some actions of God... are eternal. Actions like God's glory or God's love, these are eternal energies, actions, attributes.”
- Other speaker: Thomism conflates divine attributes with created effects, leading to theological confusion.“If mercy and justice are the exact same thing as love... then we don't actually ever know when or what is being experienced.”
- Jay Dyer: The essence-energy distinction shows how we know God without becoming one with His essence.“this is what the essence energy distinction is about.”
- Other speaker: Philosophical speculation cannot lead us to knowledge of God; revelation is necessary.“We only know what God reveals to us.”
via Cappadocian Fathers- Unclear speaker: Inner prayer is crucial for understanding God and is supported by St. Gregory's teachings.“how to pray, how we pray”
Subjects
11Jay presents St. Gregory Palamas's perspective that the doctrine of paganism is demonic and that apophatic theology gives a true teaching from Mosaic Revelation.
Jay critiques Barlam's view that natural theology can provide true revelations about God and asserts that God's oneness cannot be understood through philosophical speculation.
Jay defines apophatic theology as the belief that what God is cannot be known or named, indicating that God is ineffable and beyond human comprehension.
Jay mentions Paul's experiences of the uncreated glory as foundational for understanding St. Gregory's hesychastic theology, highlighting the significance of Paul's vision of God.
Jay refers to Saint Benedict as an example of a saint who understood the divine light and the knowledge of God through participation.
Jay critiques absolute simplicity, arguing that it undermines the very cohesion of Christian doctrine and leads to problematic theological implications.
Jay asserts that Palamism represents a correct understanding of the essence-energy distinction, which he argues is misinterpreted by Thomism.
Jay critiques the Thomistic understanding of predestination for being too closely related to divine essence, which he argues skews Christology.
Jay refers to St. John of Damascus' arguments favoring the unity and simplicity of God in countering Thomism.
Jay discusses the Trinity, emphasizing how absolute simplicity could lead to heretical conclusions regarding the crucifixion of the Father.
Jay argues that Thomism conflates essential divine attributes with created effects, thus leading to a compromised understanding of God.