Content

Why I Became Orthodox - Jay Dyer

videoJay Dyer2018-12-16watch ↗

In this piece, Jay Dyer narrates his journey to Eastern Orthodoxy, detailing his theological struggles as he moved away from his evangelical and Calvinist upbringing. He explores his disillusionments with Protestantism and Roman Catholicism, particularly examining the issues surrounding Sedevacantism and the challenges he faced in finding a welcoming Orthodox community. Dyer discusses his extensive reading of Eastern Church Fathers and reflects on the transformative impact of Orthodox liturgy and teachings on his faith. He emphasizes the importance of humility and grace throughout his journey, attributing his conversion to God's providence and the search for authentic Christianity. Ultimately, Dyer's experience showcases a deep commitment to the truth and a rich appreciation for the traditions of the Orthodox faith.

Chain 6 steps

    • Jay Dyer: He transitioned into Calvinism and began to engage with church history.“I got into Calvinism, biblical theology.”
    • Jay Dyer: Ultimately, he embraced Eastern Orthodoxy as a cohesive solution to his theological concerns.“my journey into Orthodoxy”
    • Jay Dyer: He left a church that welcomed Freemasonry.“They said they love Freemasonry and all Freemasons are welcomed”
    • Jay Dyer: Jay emphasizes the importance of re-engaging with the roots of his faith, particularly through the Old Testament and Church Fathers.“I went back, reread the entire Old Testament several times through”
    via Orthodox theology
    • Jay Dyer: Jay reflects on his eventual return to Orthodoxy after years of doubt, finding a local church to join.“you have a local church like that to join”
    • Jay Dyer: These criticisms about his commitment show a lack of understanding of the catechumen role in the church.“this is why catechumens can become martyrs.”

Subjects

17
  • Jay has an appreciation for St. Maximus and considers his works influential in his return to Orthodoxy.

  • Jay Dyer discusses his journey towards Orthodoxy, emphasizing its importance in his life and how it resonated with his theological explorations.

  • Jay argues against a strict legalistic view of ecumenism, suggesting a historical perspective allows for more flexibility.

  • Jay Dyer discusses how his exploration of the Church Fathers and the history of the church led him to embrace Eastern Orthodoxy after questioning Protestant and Roman Catholic beliefs.

  • Jay describes his journey through various beliefs, ultimately affirming his commitment to Orthodox Christianity.

  • Jay Dyer critiques Calvinism for lacking sustainability from both historical and biblical perspectives, leading him to reject its principles.

  • Jay Dyer argues that Sedevacantism, the belief that the papacy has been vacant since Vatican II, is an untenable position leading many to despair.

  • Jay Dyer references Alistair McGrath's writings regarding the history of the doctrine of justification, which influenced his theological shifts.

  • Jay refers to Apollos as an example of someone who was an effective apologist and disciple without being chrismated.

  • Jay Dyer describes his extensive reading of St. Augustine, which was foundational to his early theological development within Calvinism.

  • Jay Dyer expresses that he began reading the Eastern Church Fathers after being immersed in the Latin Church Fathers.

  • Jay critiques the works of Romanides as part of his theological exploration.