Content

Refuting Roman Catholicism & Ecumenism: Palamas, Aquinas & Augustine - Jay Dyer

videoJay Dyer2017-09-24watch ↗

In his video, Jay Dyer critiques Roman Catholic theology, focusing on the doctrines of divine simplicity and the procession of the Holy Spirit, to highlight the fundamental differences between Eastern Orthodoxy and Western Christianity. He reflects on his history as a Thomist while emphasizing the irreconcilable views held by the two traditions, particularly concerning the essence-energy distinction and the nature of grace and deification. Dyer argues that Roman Catholic interpretations, influenced by theologians like Augustine and Aquinas, lead to serious misinterpretations of God's essence and operations, which he believes could result in Arianism. He firmly defends Orthodox theology, specifically the teachings of Gregory Palamas, and calls for a clearer distinction between the two traditions, rejecting attempts at ecumenism and blending their beliefs.

Chain 6 steps

    • Jay Dyer: The doctrine of divine simplicity in Thomism leads to various theological issues.“there are numerous problems that result from the starting point of this doctrine of absolute divine simplicity”
    • Jay Dyer: In Augustine's text, the righteousness we receive is not the same as God's righteousness, which implies it is a created habit, not an actual participatory grace from God.“if it's not the righteousness by which God is righteous, it's an infused created habit”
    • Jay Dyer: Augustine's views lead to confusion about God's nature, which can result in Arianism.“your presuppositions of divine simplicity lead to Arianism.”
    • Jay Dyer: The beatific vision as understood by Aquinas lacks a proper relationship with the body.“Aquinas' resurrection doctrine has almost absolutely no place for the body”
    • Jay Dyer: Eastern Orthodox theology, as exemplified by Gregory Palamas, clarifies the monarchy of the Father.“if you really want to get clear on this I recommend the book... by Gregorios Mansurites”
    • Jay Dyer: Challenges anyone to debate on these theological distinctions.“I open the challenge here Eric Ibarra or any of these characters if you want to come on and do a real formal public debate”

Subjects

6
  • Jay Dyer presents the view that Gregory Palamas insists on a clear distinction between essence and energy in God, allowing for the proper procession of the Holy Spirit from the Father.

  • Jay critiques Augustine's notion of divine simplicity and his identification of God's operations with His essence, arguing that this leads to inconsistencies in Roman Catholic theology.

  • Jay presents the argument that Thomas Aquinas' doctrine of divine simplicity is incompatible with Eastern Orthodox theology, particularly regarding the distinction between God's essence and energies.

  • Jay refers to the Council of Trent as adopting the notion of infused grace, which he critiques as inconsistent with biblical theology and Orthodox beliefs.

  • Jay Dyer expresses a rejection of Freemasonry, linking it to issues within Roman Catholicism and emphasizing its historical opposition in papal encyclicals.

  • Jay references Origen's views in discussing the problematic implications of divine simplicity that could lead to Arianism.