Content

Anselm's Ontological Argument & John Duns Scotus - Dyer / Fr Sorem

videoJay DyerFr. Sorem2019-12-14watch β†—

In his discussions, Jay Dyer engages deeply with the theological contributions of Anselm and John Duns Scotus, contrasting their views with Eastern Orthodox perspectives. He critiques Anselm's ontological argument and the implications of absolute divine simplicity, arguing that these concepts fail to adequately reflect a personal God as understood in Orthodox theology. Dyer also examines Scotus's ideas, particularly his acceptance of natural theology, positing that this diverges from traditional Orthodox beliefs about divine revelation and the essence-energy distinction. Throughout the dialogues, he emphasizes the importance of this distinction for understanding God and Christology, ultimately asserting that both Anselm and Scotus's frameworks do not align with the core tenets of Eastern Orthodoxy. Additionally, the discussions touch on broader theological ramifications, including issues of divine justice and the critiques of Western theological frameworks like Calvinism.

Chain 6 steps

    • Jay Dyer: Augustine's doctrine of predestination presents challenges to the understanding of the incarnationβ€œif Augustine's doctrine of predestination is correct, then...”
    • Jay Dyer: The fall affects human perception of God's revelation in the natural world, leading to misconceptions about natural theology's role.β€œit's not a fault of the world revealing God.”
    via John Thomas
    • Jay Dyer: Argues that Scotus's cosmological argument relies on assumptions that do not align with Christian doctrine.β€œScotus moves on to consider in a very philosophically dense way, the first being”
    • Jay Dyer: Attempts to reconcile Thomism and Scotism lead to incoherence.β€œThe formal distinction...does not achieve what it attempts to achieve.”
    • Jay Dyer: Anselm's argument leads to a conclusion of a generic unity rather than a personal God.β€œit doesn't actually prove a personal God”
    • Jay Dyer: Anselm's satisfaction theory contributed to the development of penal substitution in Reformation theology.β€œI would add to the divine atonement, the divine satisfaction theory, which is really pioneered here in Anselm.”

Subjects

20
  • Jay critiques John Duns Scotus's views on the existence of God, arguing that he accepts a univocal understanding of being which contradicts Orthodox theology and his notion of natural theology diverges from traditional views.

  • Jay critiques Anselm on the basis that his reasoning is flawed and relies on Neoplatonic assumptions, rendering his arguments incompatible with Orthodoxy.

  • Jay critiques Anselm's ontological argument, stating that it assumes existence as a predicate and fails to prove a personal God, leading to a concept of a generic monadic unity instead.

  • Jay highlights the issues with Augustine's doctrine of predestination and its implications on Christology, arguing it leads to significant theological problems.

  • Jay Dyer appreciates Jerry Matatix as an intelligent and honest interlocutor, noting they will likely engage in discussions about Vatican II and debate set of a contest versus Orthodoxy.

  • Jay compares Scotus's arguments to those of Thomas Aquinas, noting their shared Aristotelian foundations but highlighting significant theological discrepancies.

  • Jay argues that Calvinism affirms absolute divine simplicity and the filioque, and critiques its view of God's will as necessary and predetermined.

  • Jay Dyer expresses interest in discussing the formation of the canon and canonicity, sharing that he has researched this topic extensively with literature ready for review.

  • Jay argues that the concept of absolute divine simplicity, as understood in Anselm's framework, leads to a critique where unity is assumed to be more metaphysically primary than multiplicity, which he believes distorts the understanding of God.

  • Jay describes Eastern Orthodoxy's distinct approach to theology, emphasizing the presuppositional nature of Orthodox thought as opposed to natural theology.

  • Jay critiques the penal substitution view as evolving from Anselm's satisfaction theory, leading to heretical outcomes regarding the Trinity.

  • Jay mentions Pascal to illustrate the idea that human sin affects our perception of God's existence and truth.