Universalism? Origenism Refuted - Jay, Snek, David, Fr Dcn Ananias
In this discussion, Jay Dyer and his guests analyze the controversies surrounding Origenism and its association with universalism, highlighting how Origen's teachings have been repeatedly condemned by ecumenical councils. They argue that Origen's influence has led to severe misunderstandings of Christian doctrine, particularly concerning the nature of hell, salvation, and the resurrection of the body. The speakers emphasize the importance of adhering to traditional Orthodox beliefs, arguing that Origen's integration of Neoplatonism and his ideas on free will pose significant theological risks. Furthermore, they explore the implications of universalism on concepts of God's justice and mercy, asserting that such beliefs conflict with essential tenets of Christian faith. Overall, the discussion serves as a strong critique of Origen's philosophies and their impact on contemporary theology, reinforcing the necessity for a clear and authoritative understanding of Orthodox doctrine.
Chain 6 steps
- Fr Dcn Ananias: The councils made clear distinctions regarding the condemnations connected to Origen.“you do not see it in the Fifth Council for Origins, you do not see it in the Sixth Council for Origins.”
- Jay Dyer: Saints condemned Origen's ideas even soon after his death, indicating historical opposition to his teachings.“one of the saints in his day...had looked at his writings and realized that it was heretical.”
- Jay Dyer: Origen's teachings are condemned for denying historical creation.“...Origen is actually condemned for denying the existence of a historical Eden...”
- Jay Dyer: Hellenic philosophy presents the body as a prison, affecting views on resurrection.“the Greeks have a hard time with the resurrection they think it's foolishness”
- Jay Dyer: Augustine's framework still accommodates free choice despite his emphasis on divine simplicity.“augustine's doctrine of genesis souls are created but they're able to choose between good and evil”
via Ben Shapiro- Jay Dyer: Maximus addresses and refutes the issues stemming from Origenism in his writings.“many of them are dealing with originist problems”
Subjects
18Jay critiques Origen's doctrines, particularly his views on simplicity and the relationship between the Father and Son, pointing out their problematic implications within Christian theology.
Jay mentions Saint Maximus' doctrines and critiques modern theologians who misconstrue his teachings in relation to Origen.
Jay argues that Origen's views introduce problematic notions of subordination within the Trinity, particularly regarding the relationship between the Father and Son.
Jay critiques David Bentley Hart's misunderstandings regarding Origen's theological concepts during the discussion.
Jay references the writings of Saint John of Damascus to support the condemnation of Origen's ideas, emphasizing that they are consistently rejected in the Orthodox tradition.
Jay explains Augustine's views as still retaining a dialectical understanding of free will and contrasts them with Origen's.
Jay notes the Council of Chalcedon's role in defining orthodox positions which Origenism undermines.
Jay mentions the condemnation of certain views of apocatastasis by references to the Council of Constantinople, stressing the church's position against universalism.
Jay and his guests argue that the condemnation of Origen is well established in historical ecclesiastical authority, especially through ecumenical councils.
Jay discusses the eschatological implications of free will and salvation in light of different theological viewpoints.
Jay links Eunomius to Origen's doctrines, noting that Eunomius built consistently on Origenist assumptions, particularly regarding simplicity and essence.
Jay notes that Hellenic philosophy presents a negative view of the body, viewing it as a prison, and this influences Origen's theological assumptions.