Orthodox Critique of Aquinas' Divine Simplicity and Created Grace - Jay Dyer
Jay Dyer critiques Thomas Aquinas' perspectives on created grace and divine simplicity, questioning the Thomistic notion that created intellects can see God through a mediating created light. He argues that Aquinas' assertion of God's essence being identical to his attributes leads to an impersonal view of God, where the will and intellect are not distinct from the divine essence. Dyer contrasts this with Eastern Orthodox theology, emphasizing the significance of the essence-energies distinction and asserting that Aquinas' interpretation results in a monadic view of divinity that neglects personal distinctions within the Trinity. Ultimately, he stresses the importance of recognizing God's essence as separate from created means, arguing that true theosis and the direct vision of God cannot be achieved through anything created.
Chain 5 steps
- Unclear speaker: Comparison of Aquinas and Eastern Orthodox views.βAquinas' framework leads to a monadic conception of divinity.β
- Other speaker: True theosis is face-to-face interaction with the Logos.β...what was a rare occurrence in the Old Covenant is going to be normative for us in the New Covenant.β
- Other speaker: Aquinas' teaching on divine simplicity undermines personal distinction in God.βThe distinctions that we make about God as humans are formal. They don't exist in Ray, in reality.β
- Jay Dyer: Rejection of essence-energies distinction by Aquinas.βAquinas rejects John Damascus' arguments for the essence-energy distinction.β
- Other speaker: Aquinas' view leads to an impersonal conception of God.β...God's will is his essence... God is just a big impersonal monad.β
Subjects
3Jay critiques Thomas Aquinasβ concept of created grace as incompatible with the idea of divine simplicity, arguing that it conflates the essence of God with created intelligence.
Jay mentions St. Maximus but critiques his approach compared to Aquinas' regarding divine archetypes in the divine essence.
Jay argues that Aquinas rejects John of Damascus' arguments for the essence-energy distinction.