Death of Reason: Natural Theology in Rome & Orthodoxy - Fr Dcn Dr Aanias / Jay Dyer
In their discussions, Jay Dyer and Father Deacon Dr. Ananias delve into the complex relationship between natural theology and Orthodox Christian beliefs, contrasting this with the Roman Catholic tradition. They critique the Western approach to natural theology, emphasizing the distinct role of faith and divine revelation in Orthodox thought. The dialogue highlights historical figures and their influences, such as Saint Maximus the Confessor and Thomas Aquinas, while critiquing empirical theology and classical foundationalism for inadequacies in understanding God's nature. They argue for the importance of repentance and grace in gaining true knowledge, asserting that theological insights cannot be fully achieved through empirical means alone. This exploration ultimately underscores the significant philosophical divergences between Eastern and Western theological frameworks, particularly relating to concepts like divine simplicity and the Trinity.
Chain 6 steps
- Jay Dyer: Even though St. Gregory Palamas rejects Hellenism, he still agrees that philosophy can sometimes be beneficial.“it's not because of their paganism. It's in spite of their paganism, you see.”
via natural theology- Jay Dyer: Orthodox theology employs a different interpretation of God's nature compared to Western theology.“God is and it is not a first cause.”
- Jay Dyer: True knowledge of the world necessitates repentance.“natural knowledge also requires repentance.”
via Maximus the Confessor- Jay Dyer: Natural and supernatural revelation are intrinsically linked.“Natural revelation is known and understood fully in the light of supernatural.”
- Jay Dyer: Classical foundationalism fails to account for the complexity of knowledge and belief systems.“So what you get with, uh, uh, uh, Van Orman Quine,...”
- Jay Dyer: Natural theology is fundamentally flawed regarding divine truth.“Is it possible to discover a natural proof for the Trinity?”
Subjects
33Jay Dyer critiques Aquinas for spending 300 pages establishing a simple essence without addressing the Trinity.
Jay discusses how natural theology has undergone a transformation within Christian thought, particularly from a Hellenistic perspective to an Orthodox understanding.
Jay critiques classical foundationalism for its reliance on circular reasoning and the presentation of knowledge from sense data.
Jay critiques empiricism for its inability to account for immaterial objects and for the logical inadequacies it presents, especially regarding knowledge and causation.
Jay Dyer cites St. Gregor Palamas in reference to the distinction between types of divine energies, emphasizing that some energies relate to creation and do not compromise God's immutability.
Jay references John's arguments for the essence-energy distinction, rejected by Aquinas due to implications of composition.
Jay Dyer claims that Maximus the Confessor's views indicate that the entire universe participates in theosis, stressing that individual will determines eternal outcomes.
Jay critiques the application of Aristotle's logic and foundationalism in empirical theology.
Jay references Tertullian's view on philosophy's relationship with faith and the dangers of blending Hellenistic thought with Christianity.
Jay mentions that St. Gregory of Nyssa studied Origin, noting that historical context matters in evaluating his thought.
Jay discusses Darwin's approach to explaining apparent purpose in nature within a materialistic framework.
Jay suggests that St. Vladimir's Seminary has adopted liberal and ecumenist positions, which some see as problematic.